Look, it's fine if you want to read casually. Reading as a fun hobby is 100% awesome.
HOWEVER, if you want to start slinging around the "[insert book title] is just a knock off of [insert most popular book in the same genre]" you sure as heck better have a solid grasp of tropes, genre expectations, and genre history.
Way too often, people assume that the first place they read something is where that thing originated from. Reality is that writers (like all artists), consciously or not, are drawing from an existing literary canon that goes back decades, centuries, or, in some cases, millennia.
George R. R. Martin did not invent child loss (as one commentor on my YouTube seemed to think). Nor did he invent eastern and western continents (as another commentor on YouTube seemed to think).
Frank Herbert did not invent the "women with power scary" trope, nor did he invent the Doomed Chosen One (aka Jesus) or the "noble savage" trope. I have a lot of issues with Robert Jordan and The Wheel of Time, but no, he did not "rip off" Dune.
(While we're at it, no, Sarah J. Maas did not invent fairy courts or shadow daddies.)
It's fine to not be an expert. Perfectly fine!
But if you want to start making accusations, you better have done your research.
...readmore